Dinner delivery & gifts
We specialize in classic comfort food made with fresh ingredients. Our dinner delivery menu changes monthly to add interest and variety to our many loyal, repeat customers.
Our customers include busy families, professionals, retirees and people with mobility concerns ... anyone and everyone who could use help making dinner.
Dinner delivery is a thoughtful, useful and unique gift. About half of our orders are given as gifts to families with new babies and people coping with illness or loss.
We deliver to Milwaukee and Waukesha Counties and ship meals throughout Wisconsin, Illinois and Minnesota.
NOTE: We’re moving! Meal making and delivery service on hold beginning Dec. 19 and through transition. Read more…
Comfort food classics, with a fresh twist
Our menu isn't fancy or exotic. It's just darn good food made with fresh ingredients. It's the kind of food your mom or grandma used to make - but without the condensed soup.
Our menu changes monthly and includes oven-ready casseroles, skillet meals and crock/Instant pot kits. We also offer fresh salads, as well as cobblers, cakes and bars for dessert.
We rotate options that are gluten-free, soy-free, dairy-free, low-carb and vegetarian.
See what's cooking today.
Oven-ready casseroles, skillet meals and crock/Instant pot kits
Meals made fresh weekly
We use fresh, whole ingredients to make wholesome meals for you to enjoy at home. Our tried and true recipes have been passed down for generations and our customers often remark on the "homemade" quality dishes.
Our oven-ready casseroles, skillet meals and instant/crock pot kits are made to order in our commercial kitchen on Mondays and Tuesdays, then frozen to ensure food safety during delivery on Wednesdays. Our meals are freezer friendly for up to 3 months, making it easy to stock up on hassle-free, thaw-and-bake meals.
Portions for every appetite
Whether dining solo or feeding a crowd, we serve every appetite. Meals are available in the following sizes:
- Small (1-3 servings)
- Medium (4-5 servings)
- Large (6-8 servings)
- 4-pack microwavable singles (Available only on select meals.)
Our large meal size is roughly the size of a 9x13" casserole dish. Love leftovers? Consider ordering a size larger to get several meals out of one pan.
Our meals are delivered fully prepared and ready to pop in the oven, a skillet or in the microwave -- the perfect dinner solution for busy families, professionals, retirees and people with mobility concerns.
Our crock and instant pot kits are delivered fully prepped, perfectly portioned and with everything needed to make dinner at home. Simply follow our instructions to cook in your slow cooker or electronic pressure cooker. We also offer grill-ready options during warm weather months.
How we're different
A unique business serving a need
Cream City Casseroles is not a traditional restaurant or meal kit company. Since 2015, we've operated as a part-time, prepared meal delivery service serving southeast Wisconsin and parts of the midwest.
Hassle-free meals, prepared locally, no subscription required
With other meal delivery services, you're shipped a box of ingredients (from heaven knows where) to assemble and cook. Our meals are prepared for you locally. Simply heat, eat and enjoy.
There's no subscription required. Simply order what you need. We'll make and deliver it when you'd like. No pressure. No commitment.
How to order
Customers order online or by phone anytime through 5 p.m. Sunday. We make all meals fresh in our commercial kitchen Mondays & Tuesdays. Order by 5 p.m. Sunday for delivery the following Wednesday.
We offer free delivery to Milwaukee and Waukesha Counties on orders of $40 or more every Wednesday between 11 a.m. - 5 p.m. Add one of our insulated bags with an ice pack or leave a cooler on your doorstep on delivery day.
We ship throughout Wisconsin, Illinois and Minnesota
We're happy to pack your order on dry ice and in an insulated box for shipping via next-day ground service. We charge a $25 flat-rate (regardless of order size/weight) to cover the cost of shipping materials.
Pick-up available by appointment
Please make an appointment to visit our kitchen to pick up orders. We keep somewhat irregular hours and need to make sure someone's available to assist you.
Pick-up is available Wednesdays - Fridays from 7:30 a.m. - 4 p.m. Appointments required.
Cream City Casseroles operates from a commercial kitchen in Waukesha, WI owned by Easterseals of Southeast Wisconsin. The kitchen serves as a classroom to train people with disabilities for food service jobs, including prep/line cooks, servers and dishwashers.
Renting this amazing facility helps Cream City Casseroles keep overhead and prices low while helping fund Easterseals' training program. It's an incredible win/win.
Cream City Casseroles is licensed, certified and insured.
Show you care.
Send a meal.
Thoughtful. Unique. Deeply appreciated.
Sending a meal is one of the oldest and best ways to show you care. Our oven-ready meal delivery is a thoughtful, useful way to celebrate new babies, welcome new neighbors and help friends in need.
Gift deliveries, Care packages & gift cards
We offer 3 ways to send meals:
- You hand-pick the meals
- Care Package (4-pack of meals + bag)
- Gift cards
To ensure prompt and safe delivery, we contact gift recipients within 24 hours of delivery.
You hand-pick meals
Visit our menu and place an order, selecting meals for your gift recipient. At checkout, provide the gift recipient's delivery information and pick your preferred delivery date. We recommend adding a personal message and insulated bag/ice pack for a beautiful presentation and to ensure food safety during delivery.
Care packages are a great way to support someone coping with a prolonged illness/recovery or when caring for an older adult.
Send a 4-pack of oven-ready meals delivered in our signature insulated bag with ice pack. Choose the meal size (small: 1-3 servings, medium: 4-5 servings or large: 6-8 servings) and if you'd like a one-time delivery or to have meals delivered once a month for 3, 6 or 12 months.
The meals are delivered frozen, labeled with a complete list of ingredients and with easy thaw-and-bake instructions. Meals are freezer friendly for up to 3 months, making it easy to help a someone you care about stock up on wholesome, hassle-free meals.
A Cream City Casseroles gift card lets the recipient select their own meals and delivery date. Gift cards are available in any denomination and are issued to you by email immediately upon confirming your order. (You can print or forward the gift card, as needed.) Unused gift card balances may be applied toward future purchases.
Dinner delivery is a thoughtful gift for co-workers on medical or bereavement leave, FMLA or to support someone going through a tough/stressful time.